Garrett R.

As soon as I found this was one of those penny auction sites I tried to unsubscribe to all the emails. Good luck. I finally stopped receiving loads of extra crap email, but it was a pain. Auction websites like this are a joke anyway.

Ideeli was the first of the online TJ Maxx/Marshalls/etc sites that I ever used. It has certainly contributed a fair amount to my wardrobe.
Shipping:
I generally find the shipping from Ideeli to be, well, ideal. The other sites HauteLook, JackThreads, Fab, etc all seem to have made me wait longer than Ideeli ever has before shipping out my item(s). They also only make you pay once a day for shipping, which is genius for a site that promotes such impulse purchases as this genre does.
Checkout Process:
As a website designer that has worked on User Experience, Ideeli blew me away. There whole checkout process is meticulously geared at getting you to confirm your purchase without really thinking twice. Because of this, be careful with this website if you don't have the purchasing liberty granted by large amounts of disposable income.
Variety:
They tend towards the higher end items but for pretty deep discounts. They upgraded me to the advanced member section free for 3 months so I could get in on sales before they sold out. That was a bit of a waste. I didn't find that I had any more spectacular options for savings. This may very well be different if I wasn't a male. The site obviously has far more options for females. Blast! But welcome to the plight of the fashionable, straight male.
Overall, I like Ideeli and check it regularly. They have solid customer support and I have yet to be 'screwed over' by them. However, I have found myself ordering from Jack Threads more of late; mainly because they carry more casual summer wear options for young men.

I have purchased two watches from Watchismo in the past few months. Both were towards the lower price range of their selection in the $120-$160 area.
Return Policy:
I was fairly nervous about the return policy because both watches are pretty ostentatious and 'fashionable' so I had no idea if I would actually like them in person. The return policy states that if they watches are more than 20% off the normal price, sorry, no returns. Both of the watches I bought were marked at well over 20% off. One could only be ordered from Watchismo (foreign watch maker and watchismo is the only licensed dealer/importer in America) and the other was $120 less than I could find anywhere else. I was confident that if I absolutely hated the watches, I could sell both pretty easily on eBay so I pulled the trigger despite the crappy return policy.
Shipping:
Super reasonable shipping charges. I opted for 2-3 day shipping each time because it was only $3-5 more. Each watch arrived 2 days after I placed the order, which is impressive. Good job, Watchismo.
Selection:
Each of these watches was exactly as I expected it to be based on the pictures. They make up the 'weekend' portion of my watch collection and I receive compliments on them every time I wear them out.
Conclusion:
If you want a unique watch that will ship her fast, check out Watchismo, but be ready to seek alternate means of exchanging the watch if you get a good deal on it and you don't end up loving it.