I have been a Macy's customer for many years, spending hundreds of dollars annually. For the upcoming year, my plan is to spend as little as possible and ONLY after checking other stores...
Reasons:
A) two items that I ordered recently (a national women's clothing brand): one delivered but wrong item, the other lost in space. I ended up finding the item at Kohl's online for less than Macy's price--which had been marked down twice!
B) star rewards: a scam. Yes, they do award the $10 bonus when you hit 1k points on shopping but they are extremely arbitrary in how they award them. After my two recent returns (total of less than $50), my rewards pts went from nearly 1,000 to about 300. Why? Well, total of two hours on two separate occasions with their online chat was useless... contradictions and false information.
C) sale passes: I have been getting those for years and could count on one hand the number of times they actually worked. The fine print/exclusions are so extensive they look like a page from the phonebook.
D) I pay off my bill each month, both store and Amex, which I rarely use. I just happened to notice recently that the interest rate on carryovers was over 30%! Are you kidding me? How is that even legal?
E) most of all, as my recent experience with online Kohls' showed (as well as buying items like Patricia Nash scarf online@ HSN), Macy's is virtually never the best price.
Also, I have emailed numerous times and have NEVER got a reply.
If I were ever in a Macy's store and saw something that was a great sale, I might buy it.
But for the most part, I am pretty much done with Macy;s.