The Real Real sold my mom a counterfeit bright green Herve Leger dress. I knew it was a fake the minute I saw and tried on the dress. The label was off, the finish was awful and the elasticity was gone. I have 20+ year old Herve dresses that are as elastic as the day I bought them.
I reported a pair of counterfeit Chanel and a pair of Valentino Rockstud flats they had for sale. 1 sold (I asked they refund the buyer), the other unsold (I asked they remove it from the site).
By the time they got back to me after "looking into it", the 2nd pair sold. They said they marked the shoes as "sold", so no one could buy them and gave me $50 credit probably to keep my mouth shut about it.
What kind of reputable site, that prides itself in having top authenticators and selling ONLY AUTHENTIC items, is dumb enough to show COUNTERFEIT ITEMS as SOLD on their website? None, so basically they thought I was dumb enough to believe their story.
Also, if you consign to them, be aware that because of their continuous 20% off offer to buyers, you'll never receive a 60% or 70% comission. Say you consigned a top for $100. I buy it using the 20% off and pay $80. You'll get paid 60% or 70% of $80, which in reality is 48% or 56%.
Now that I got the scary stuff out of the way, I'll go on with the good. I've bought 3 pair of Margiela shoes and they were fine. One was kind of dirty inside, but that can be fixed.
My mom has gotten decent deals on Gianvito Rossi, Celine shoes, Pucci, etc.
My final word on the Real Real is:
- DON'T consign with them. They don't pay enough, they don't pay the % promised and at times they underprice and mislabel things. They've even rejected consigning items that were sold by them. How about that? I'd love if they said it's because the item is fake lol
-DON'T buy anything mainstream that can be faked! If you're afraid to buy it on eBay, don't buy it here either, UNLESS: IT CAN BE RETURNED (not all items can) AND:
A- You can authenticate it yourself and tell the real from the fake*
B- Pay a fee and have it authenticated it by a reputable 3rd party
- DO buy brands/styles that are not known to be counterfeited, IF you find a good deal. I say if because at times they price it close to retail (some Valentino Rockstud shoes). If in doubt, Google fake xyz. I googled the green Herve I bought from them & found it on a fake website. The real Herve of this style has less bandages on the bust.