Made my first photo book at Shutterfly, had an AWFUL, TERRIBLE, BAD experience. Customer service is awful, nobody wants to address problems, no one wants to take responsibility - don't use Shutterfly (read all of the bad reviews).
When it came time to make another book I went to Montage Book and am so glad I did. The book was made & delivered really fast, the quality is great, the pages are nice and thick. One of my favorite things about this book is the collage of all the photos in your book that they make at the front and back of the book. These guys are GREAT! And my montagebook cost 1/2 of my Shutterfly book.