Don't buy the solid, it smells like mildew. I bought three different scents in a bundle and they went bad before I could even use them. The cream stick is fine. Also, it doesn't last for 72 hours. It's effective for maybe 24 hours. I've been using this product since it came out. They told me the shelf life is 1 year open and 2 years unopened. Obviously, this isn't true. I bought the bundle 5 months ago and they are all bad. Company won't send me replacements because it's out of their 30 day warranty. I'm very disappointed in them. I've been a loyal customer for many years. Another thing to note is that the body wipes burn your private parts, they're ok for arm pits. They offered me a 15% off coupon but, I won't be supporting them anymore. They tried to tell me it was about "my scent preference " I don't think anyone wants to smell like a dirty dish rag. They've lost me as a customer.