Been ordering from them for literal years, never had a bad experience with them. Some jewelry has been lower quality than expected (cheap jewelry that's. Cheap. Duh), although most has far surpassed my expectations. And it's not like they're sitting there making the jewelry before they send it out, so, keep that in mind. The selection is *chefs kiss* magnifique, almost too good because I always manage to see One More Thing after telling myself I'm gonna place my order and be done. Pricing is good. They are quite on top of customer service and pleasant to work with. I gave a poor review of a disappointing piece of jewelry from within their site (a dirt cheap tongue ring so I didn't care that it sucked, just wanted to warn others!) and they credited me the 1 or 2 bucks that it cost without me asking. Nice! Shipping is always super fast. It's honestly so awesome, I love this site to death. By the way- many people here seem pissed about things shipping in one bag, so just a heads up, that's an option that you can toggle on or off at checkout!
Thanks BAF!