I purchased Bulk Apothecary's 1 Gallon unscented massage lotion & the premium massage lotion. Both were a total disappointment. Both products are Water Based and if you add oil, you'll just notice the oil floating on top. The lotion dries very quickly, so if you apply the lotion within 20 seconds it dries completely. I've definitely used better. As for the Ratings for this product - Wish I checked before I purchased. All the reviews are from 2016 - 2019... and here we are at 2021.