I used to buy my anime VHS tapes from this site, that's how long I've been a dedicated customer. I've only ever had 1 problem with shipping, when a Tenchi Universe box set I bought never arrived. Customer service had a replacement shipped out and at my doorstep within a week. Sadly the great company that existed back then is no more.
I placed a recent order for my husband's birthday. I got concerned when the tracking information hadn't updated for 5 weeks. I first tried contacting them through their route app. Claim instantly denied for being over 30 days old. Reached out to their customer service website, was sent a claim form with instructions to 1. First file a claim with USPS, then once their investigation was over, 2. Attach it to their claim form, which requests LEGAL consent and wait for their investigation to commence. Needless to say I didn't want to wait another 2-6 months for a replacement or refund. Luckily I use PayPal for most of online purchases so I have some buyer protection.
Just like similar reviews as soon as PayPal found in my favor, RightStuf quickly moved to ban my account. If only they showed as much enthusiasm in helping their customers? I'm fine saying goodbye with ZERO regrets. No sense supporting a business that doesn't exist anymore. I'll miss you RightStuf for what you were but certainly not what you are now. Great customer service is at the heart of customer loyalty but clearly you no longer care.